It usually happens at the end of the month.
You open the payout report, scroll past the bookings, and land on the line you’ve learned to dread: platform fees. You do the math in your head. Then you do it again, slower, because the first number can’t be right.
It is, and this fall it got worse. Airbnb’s host-only fee sits at 15.5% for most PMS-connected hosts. Vrbo’s commission jumped to 12% on October 29. And on November 20, Airbnb’s new house rules start telling you what you can and can’t ask of guests in your own home.
So you type a question into Google, half hoping someone will give you permission:
Should I remove my property from OTAs and focus on direct bookings?
I know that question well. It’s one of the questions that brings operators to my site every month. I’ve asked it myself, sitting where you’re sitting, staring at a business that felt like it belonged to someone else.
Here’s the honest answer, the data behind it, and what I’d do instead.
No, not yet. And for most operators, never completely.
Removing your property from OTAs before you’ve built demand of your own doesn’t free you from the platforms. It just empties your calendar. The right move is to build direct demand alongside your OTA listings, then pull back gradually, channel by channel and date by date, as your own demand proves it can fill the nights.
That’s not the answer the frustration wants. But the numbers are hard to argue with.
So if you remove your property from OTAs today, you’re not leaving a bad landlord. You’re walking away from where more than half of your future guests are standing, before you’ve built anywhere else for them to go.
Every host remembers launching their first listing.
No reviews. No booking history. You priced it low to get the first few stays. You answered every message within minutes. You obsessed over the first ten reviews, because you knew nobody books the place with zero stars and no photos of real guests on the porch. It took months before that listing earned a steady calendar, and only then did it start booking on its own.
Your direct booking channel is that listing, all over again.
It starts with zero reviews from the traveler’s point of view. They don’t know your brand. They haven’t seen your guests’ stories. They can’t tell whether your checkout is safe, whether your photos are real, or whether you’ll answer the phone when the hot tub won’t heat. And unlike Airbnb, there’s no algorithm handing you a new-listing boost. On your own channel, you are the algorithm.
Now picture someone with a 4.9-star listing and 300 reviews deleting it to launch a brand-new one from scratch, and expecting the calendar to stay full. You’d tell them to stop. Keep the listing that’s working, launch the new one beside it, and move guests over as it earns trust.
That’s the honest answer to “should I remove my property from OTAs?” You don’t delete the listing with 300 reviews. You build the new one until it can carry the load.
I’ve watched this play out enough times to know the order it happens in.
First comes the relief. No more commission line. You feel like you’ve taken your business back.
Then the calendar starts going quiet. The bookings that would have arrived next month don’t, because those guests were still searching where they always search. Your website gets visits from people who already knew you, and almost nobody else.
Then comes the discounting. You cut rates to fill the gaps, and the margin you saved on commission disappears into lower prices.
And then, a few months later, comes the quiet return to the platforms. Only now your listings have lost their momentum, you have fewer recent reviews, and you’ve spent a season you can’t get back.
Commission is an expensive way to get bookings. An empty night is a more expensive one, because it earns nothing at all. Booking Holdings CEO Glenn Fogel made exactly that point at VRMA this fall, and on that, he’s right.
The goal was never to escape the OTAs. The goal is to stop needing them for everything, so every channel becomes a choice instead of a requirement.
Here’s the part most direct booking advice skips: how long this actually takes. These are the phases I’ve seen in every system I’ve built. Your speed depends on your market, your property, and how consistently you run it.
Phase | When | What you build | What to realistically expect |
|---|---|---|---|
1. Foundation | Months 1 to 2 | A clear reason to choose you, a website that converts, email as the first field at checkout, unique booking codes in your PMS, and your current booking mix as a baseline | No change in bookings yet. What you get is a starting line you can measure from |
2. First demand engine | Months 3 to 6 | One channel that reaches travelers before they search, run every week. For me, that’s creators | Your first direct bookings you can trace to a source. A realistic six-month goal is a 10% or greater increase in direct bookings |
3. Retention kicks in | Months 6 to 12 | Post-stay emails, a returning-guest perk, seasonal and anniversary sends | Your first repeat direct guests. Direct share climbing quarter over quarter |
4. Compounding | Year 2 | More creators, partners, and referrals feeding a growing past-guest list | Direct carries enough of the calendar that you can start pulling back from OTAs on your strongest dates |
For perspective: when I started at ReTreet, 100% of our bookings came through OTAs. It took two years of steady, weekly work to reach 93% direct. That was a distinctive property with a creator engine behind it, so treat it as a ceiling, not a promise. Your number will be different. The direction shouldn’t be.
The operators who get frustrated with direct bookings almost always quit during Phase 2, right before it starts to compound. It’s the brand-new listing problem again. Nobody would judge a new listing on its first three weeks.
There is a right time to reduce your OTA exposure. It just isn’t decided by how annoyed you are with the latest fee change. It’s decided by your own numbers.
You’re ready to start pulling back when you can say yes to all four of these:
Even then, the smart move is rarely removing your property from OTAs entirely. Close the OTA calendar on the dates your direct channel can fill. Raise your OTA rates where the terms allow. Drop the one channel that isn’t earning its keep. Keep the rest working for you, filling the gaps, and introducing new guests you can bring direct next time.
That’s the shift: OTAs go from being your whole strategy to being one tool inside it.
I was employee number four at a resort that barely existed yet. Every booking we had belonged to Airbnb. If they changed something on a Tuesday, our Wednesday could vanish, and there was nothing we could do about it.
I wanted out as badly as you do. But we didn’t pull our listings. We stayed connected to the major OTAs the entire time and built our own demand beside them, one week at a time.
The engine was creators. One to two creator stays a week, every week, for two years. Every stay had a signed agreement and a brief before arrival, a tracking code on every piece of content, and a follow-up sequence after checkout. The result was 600 leads a month, a 34% conversion rate, and a shift from 100% OTA to 93% direct bookings. I later applied the same system at Wilding Hotels, where direct bookings rose 50%.
The creators weren’t magic. The system made it impossible to fail quietly. That system is what I now build for vacation rental managers.
The Creator System is a done-for-you creator marketing program. I set it up, launch it, and run it with you for six months, so you’re building the new listing while the old one keeps paying the bills.
Here’s the plan:
Two rules protect your revenue while it works. Creator stays run Sunday through Thursday only, so you never give up your best nights. And creators cover the cleaning fee and taxes in exchange for a defined set of content.
The investment is $12,000 for six months: $4,800 for setup in weeks 1 to 8, then $1,800 a month for months 3 to 6. It’s priced per portfolio, not per property. The six-month goal is a 10% or greater increase in direct bookings. That’s a target, not a guarantee, but every time I’ve built this system, direct bookings have moved in that direction.
Now put that number next to the one that brought you here. At Airbnb’s 15.5% host-only fee, any portfolio doing more than about $77,000 a year through Airbnb already pays more than $12,000 in commission. Every year. With nothing to show for it at the end but last year’s bookings.
The Creator System is a good fit if you:
It’s not a fit if you:
If you’re in the second group, that’s OK. You’ll get more from the timeline above than from hiring me.
You came here asking whether to remove your property from OTAs. You deserve a better question: what would it take for your own demand to carry the calendar, and how long would it really take for your portfolio?
That’s what the Strategy In Action Session answers. One hour, $250. We’ll look at your properties, your weekday availability, and your booking mix, and you’ll leave knowing whether the Creator System is the right move for you, or what to do instead.
Book your $250 strategy session
Not ready for a call? Start with OTA Dependence in Vacation Rentals: What VRMA 2026 Revealed for the bigger picture, or see the full Creator System program and pricing.
Not until your direct channel can carry the calendar. Removing your property from OTAs before you’ve built your own demand usually means empty nights, not freedom. Build direct demand alongside your listings, then pull back gradually on the dates your direct channel reliably fills.
Plan on months, not weeks. Expect two months to build the foundation, three to six months for your first demand channel to produce bookings you can trace, and a year or more for retention to compound. Taking a resort from 100% OTA to 93% direct took two years.
AirDNA estimates that in 2025, Airbnb took about 52% of US vacation rental nights and Vrbo about 14%. “Direct and other” accounted for about a third, which includes more than true direct bookings.
Some operators can, usually after years of building their own demand. Most can’t yet. Treat Airbnb as one channel in a mix, and use every Airbnb stay to earn a guest you can welcome back directly next time, within Airbnb’s rules.
A demand channel that reaches travelers before they search, run consistently and tracked to bookings. Creator stays with signed agreements, booking codes, and follow-up after checkout are one of the few channels that can do all three.
Sarah Stahl is a vacation rental and hospitality marketing strategist who helps operators reduce OTA dependence and grow direct bookings.
Vacation rental marketing is my whole thing. I connect marketing technology and storytelling to fix the scattered systems between a guest’s first search and their stay.
I’ve worked hospitality from every angle. I started on the government side as a tourism director at a destination marketing organization (DMO) in Northeast Alabama, running destination strategy and watching traveler behavior shift in real time. Then I moved to the private side, frustrated by brilliant property owners buried under clunky platforms and vague advice.
As Head of Marketing at ReTreet Resort, I helped grow a startup from six treehouses to 21 units and took it from fully OTA-dependent to 93% direct bookings in two years, without relying on paid search ads. The engine was a creator program: on a $30,000 annual budget, it brought in about 600 leads a month and beat revenue expectations.
I’ve worked with nearly 500 creators across travel, hospitality and local lifestyle. I speak on trust-based marketing and micro-creators at industry events, including The Uprising.
Today I work with vacation rental operators, boutique resorts, glamping and unique-stay brands, and property managers who want more direct bookings, better guest data, and a property that’s easy for both guests and AI trip planners to find.
Start here: run the free 0.15 Test to see what OTAs cost you, or take my free 5-day email course, Stop Renting Your Guests. Ready to find the broken part of your system? Click Here