Why leaning harder on Airbnb, Vrbo and Booking.com in 2027 might be the most honest decision property managers make, and the most expensive one if they simply stop there.
KeyData’s 2027 Vacation Rental Industry Outlook landed with a finding that made direct-booking evangelists wince: 25.1% of US professional property managers plan to rely more heavily on OTAs next year, while only 17.8% plan to pull back. A year earlier, the pull-back camp was bigger. (source)
The reflex in our corner of the industry is to call that backsliding. Operators got scared, took the easy bookings, gave up on direct.
I want to argue the opposite. The OTAs aren’t the problem. They never were. They’re simply the only marketing department most operators have ever paid for.
I ran a quick LinkedIn poll: “If property managers want more direct bookings, why are they planning to use OTAs more?” It drew 14 votes, so treat it as a pulse check, not a study. But the split tells a story.
What would most drive you to use OTAs more in 2027? | Share of votes |
|---|---|
More reach, more bookings | 35% |
High direct marketing costs | 28% |
Pressure to fill empty nights | 21% |
Limited team time / expertise | 14% |
When I read those together reach, cost and time are the same answer wearing different outfits. Demand generation is hard, and someone else is already doing it.
Cindy M. Rhoades, who leads Vacation Homes of Key West, named the root cause in the original thread:
“Generating demand for a hospitality business takes a level of commitment for marketing that most operators either can’t or won’t give. OTA’s are an instant fix that create dependency and an established way of doing business.”
Then she went deeper:
“The platforms have also made it remarkably easy to enter the business. A property owner can create a listing and begin accepting reservations without necessarily understanding marketing, hospitality, local regulations, or even the broader digital tools required to build an independent presence. The OTA appears to provide the entire business infrastructure.”
That last line is the whole story. The OTA appears to provide the entire business, so operators budget as if it does. Housekeeping gets a team. Maintenance gets a team. Owner relations gets a team. Revenue management gets software and a person. Demand generation gets a commission line on someone else’s platform.
Here’s my contrarian opinion, that’s not a wise trade. Paying only when a booking lands is the lowest-risk marketing contract in hospitality. No retainer, no ad spend that might flop, no hire who might not work out. Operators who choose it aren’t lazy. They’re buying certainty.
The mistake isn’t paying the invoice. It’s paying it and walking away with nothing you keep.
I keep returning to the question I asked in that thread. If an expert operator can wisely hire for every other vital pillar in the business, why does marketing keep getting overlooked? Cindy’s answer:
“Because the platforms offer immediate visibility and bookings, marketing can seem optional rather than one of the essential pillars of the business. Building a strong direct-booking platform requires expertise, sustained investment, and patience before the return is fully visible.”
Most “direct booking strategies” I see are a booking engine bolted onto a website nobody visits. That isn’t a channel. It’s a checkout page waiting for traffic the OTA already captured. Of course managers look at that and conclude OTAs deliver more reach. They’re right.
So no, I’m not going to tell you to cut OTAs. I’m going to tell you something less comfortable.
Ovidiu Pop picked “High Direct Marketing Costs,” and his reasoning deserves more airtime than our industry usually gives it:
“I chose ‘High Direct Marketing Costs’ because I operate at a very small scale, where the ROI of independent marketing would simply be unsustainable. Unfortunately, I see the industry evolving in the opposite direction, making direct acquisition even harder for small independent operators.”
That’s honest, and it’s correct. Telling a ten-unit operator to “just build your brand” is like telling a corner café to outspend DoorDash. Alone, the math doesn’t work.
Ovidiu’s way out isn’t more grit. It’s new infrastructure:
“One possible way forward would be a new generation of commission-free hotel directories, with AI-optimized listings, allowing guests to book through a hotel’s own booking system or a local booking agent. These platforms could monetize differently, through B2B advertising, supplier services or optional paid placements on destination pages, rather than booking commissions.”
He points to early movement like the Direct Booking Alliance. Whether those models scale is still an open question. The instinct is right, though: small operators beat dependency together, not one at a time.
Annie Holcombe voted for the top answer, “More Reach, More Bookings,” and still gave the clearest prescription for relying on OTAs less:
“Focus on working closer with their destination so the demand filters more direct. But also don’t use only VRBO & Airbnb. Educate owners on distribution.”
That’s three moves in three sentences:
Chris Walker with Luxury Rentals of Hilton Head, another “reach” voter, answered what would have to change:
“Your mindset. Your determination. And making small adjustments every day to improve your advantage over OTA’s.”
Stop treating OTA share as your scorecard. Track this instead: what percentage of guests who first found you on an OTA book their next stay with you directly?
That’s where the real leak is. A hostAI analysis estimates short-term rental operators pay more than $1 billion a year in OTA commissions on repeat guests. (source) Paying for the first introduction is reasonable. Paying again for a guest who already loves your property is the tax on not having a system.
Direct guests are also worth more than the commission saved. Among independent hotels, Cloudbeds found OTA bookings cancelled at 21.8% in 2025, more than double the 10.6% rate for direct bookings. (source) Different segment, same lesson: the guest you own is the guest who shows up.
Cindy closed her original post with a prediction: “As they become more predatory direct booking [will] come to the forefront again.” Maybe. But waiting for the platforms to squeeze harder is like hoping your landlord raises the rent so you’ll finally buy a house.
The managers leaning on OTAs more in 2027 aren’t the problem. The ones who lean on them more and learn nothing (no guest data, no repeat path, no brand) are paying full price for a lesson they’ll have to buy again next year.
Your turn. If you’re reducing OTA reliance, or deliberately increasing it with a plan, tell me what’s working. Join the conversation on the original poll.
Thank you to Cindy M. Rhoades, Ovidiu Pop, Annie Holcombe and Chris Walker for sharing their thinking.
Sources: KeyData 2027 outlook via ShortTermRentalz · hostAI repeat-guest commissions via TravelDailyNews · Cloudbeds 2026 State of Independent Hotels via Hotel Business · Original LinkedIn poll
Sarah Stahl is a vacation rental and hospitality marketing strategist who helps operators reduce OTA dependence and grow direct bookings.
Vacation rental marketing is my whole thing. I connect marketing technology and storytelling to fix the scattered systems between a guest’s first search and their stay.
I’ve worked hospitality from every angle. I started on the government side as a tourism director at a destination marketing organization (DMO) in Northeast Alabama, running destination strategy and watching traveler behavior shift in real time. Then I moved to the private side, frustrated by brilliant property owners buried under clunky platforms and vague advice.
As Head of Marketing at ReTreet Resort, I helped grow a startup from six treehouses to 21 units and took it from fully OTA-dependent to 93% direct bookings in two years, without relying on paid search ads. The engine was a creator program: on a $30,000 annual budget, it brought in about 600 leads a month and beat revenue expectations.
I’ve worked with nearly 500 creators across travel, hospitality and local lifestyle. I speak on trust-based marketing and micro-creators at industry events, including The Uprising.
Today I work with vacation rental operators, boutique resorts, glamping and unique-stay brands, and property managers who want more direct bookings, better guest data, and a property that’s easy for both guests and AI trip planners to find.
Start here: run the free 0.15 Test to see what OTAs cost you, or take my free 5-day email course, Stop Renting Your Guests. Ready to find the broken part of your system? Click Here